It’s summer. What’s “noon” to you?

//umbra.nascom.nasa.govThat’s really not as easy a question to answer as you might think! What do you mean by noon? Do you define it by your clock or wristwatch? Or the gnawing in your stomach that says it’s time for lunch? Well, you may want to think again!

 

The first day of summer is tomorrow, Thursday, June 21, 2007. But when noon occurs depends in part on your location, in part on your definition of “noon.” There may not be a lot to observe, but shadows tomorrow will be just a hair shorter than today or Saturday. That’s because tomorrow, at 2:06 p.m. Eastern Daylight Time, the Earth is tilted most sunward for the year and the sun rises highest in our sky, yielding the year’s shortest midday shadows. This is called the June Solstice, and you can read more about the solstice on Earth & Sky here: Solstice and on tomorrow’s radio show, as well as in Deborah Byrd’s blog.

Caption: The image is a recent photo of the sun taken from space earlier by the SOHO spacecraft. Typically these images are only a few hours old, but you will need to visit the Solar Data Analysis Center for details.

 

But notice that I said “midday”, rather than just “noon.” Usually when we say “noon” we mean 12:00 p.m. on the clock. Now, shadows are shortest when the sun is due South in the sky — we say that the sun is “crossing the meridian.” But that rarely occurs exactly at clock-time noon. The time at which the sun crosses the meridian used to be called “high noon” because that is when the sun is highest in the sky. Today we refer to this as “transit time” or “local solar noon.”

 

sunhite.gifI usually assign my students a project in which they compare the height of the sun at local solar noon to that in another location in New Mexico. This simulates an observation by Eratosthenes more than 2000 years ago, through which he obtained the first accurate measurement of the size of the earth. You can construct a simple device called a “gnomon” (pronounced “NO’-mun”) or shadow stick to calculate how high the sun is with simple trigonometry. Just measure the height of the gnomon (H) and the length of the shadow (L) at “local solar noon.” Then the angular height of the sun is the arctangent of H/L. For accuracy, the gnomon must be very straight, the ground level, and the measurements precise. Here in Denver it will be about 73.75 degrees high. How high is it where you live?

 

But before you can make the measurement, you need to know when local solar noon occurs whereever you are located. Before the invention of the telegraph in the 19th Century, every locality defined noon by the time when the sun crossed the meridian. Because of geographical location, when the sun crosses the meridian as seen from here in Denver, a little more than 180 miles to the West in Grand Junction the sun hasn’t reached the meridian yet, and won’t for another 14 minutes or so. It takes about 14 minutes for the Earth to turn far enough to bring the sun to the meridian in Grand Junction after it passes the meridian in Denver.

 

At a time when the fastest form of communication was the stage or Pony Express, this difference in time did not matter. But when near instantaneous communication became available with the telegraph, people gradually realized that a standardization of time was necessary. Thus the concept of time zones was developed in 1884 (but not adopted officially in the US until 1918!).

 

But even considering time zones, the actual time of transit varies through the year because of the Earth’s varying speed in its orbit around the sun. At times the planet has to turn a bit more from one transit to the next, and at times it needs to turn a bit less. This is because the change in Earth’s speed (due to varying distance to the sun through the year) causes the sun’s apparent motion across the sky to change. There is also a variation due to the tilt of the Earth and how that affects the sun’s apparent motion in the sky. [See comments.] That means that the real sun (which crosses the meridian at local solar noon) is as much as 16 minutes faster or slower than the steady but fictitious mean sun that defines clock-time noon for the various time zones.

 

And then of course there is the complication of “Daylight Saving Time,” which really saves nothing but merely offsets the clocks by an hour.

 

Now you can make all the calculations to figure out transit time or local solar noon for yourself, but you don’t need to go to the trouble. Just go to the U.S. Naval Observatory website and have it calculate it for you.

 

Here are some examples of transit time, or local solar noon, for tomorrow, June 21, all calculated by the Naval Observatory website:

 

Eastern Time Zone Central Time Zone Mountain Time Zone Pacific Time Zone
New York 12:57 p.m Chicago 12:52 p.m. Denver 1:02 p.m. Los Angeles 12:55 p.m.
Miami 1:23 p.m. Little Rock 1:11 p.m. Albuqueque 1:08 p.m. Seattle 1:11 p.m.
Detroit 1:34 p.m. Kansas City (KS) 1:20 p.m. Salt Lake City 1:29 p.m. San Francisco 1:12 p.m.
Atlanta 1:39 p.m. Houston 1:23 p.m. Phoenix 12:30 p.m. * Portland 1:12 p.m.

* Note that Phoenix is on Standard, not Daylight, Time. Also note that the exact moment of the Summer Solstice is not related to the time of local solar noon.

Oh, and by the way, if you’re out in the sun, don’t forget your sunblock.

4 Responses to “It’s summer. What’s “noon” to you?”


  1. 1 Bruce McClure Jun 21st, 2007 at 11:07 am

    Hi Larry!

    As a sundial enthusiast, it’s hard for me not to get excited about the concept of “noon”. The discrepancy between clock noon and solar noon, in fact, does some mind-bending things around solstice time. For instance, today’s June 21 solstice brings the longest day of the year (as measured by duration of daylight) to the northern hemisphere. Yet, at mid-northern latitudes, the earliest sunrise of the year came about a week ago; and the latest sunset of the year will come about one week after today’s summer solstice.

    That’s because the day as measured from solar noon to solar noon exceeds 24 hours at this time of year. I believe it’s something like 13 to 14 seconds longer than 24 hours. If, however, the Earth revolved around the sun in a perfect circle (and traveled at a constant speed), I believe these June days would be about 21 to 22 seconds longer than 24 hours.

    The longest days of the year, as measured from solar noon to solar noon, happen around the December solstice. Then, the solar day is about 30 seconds longer than 24 hours. Again, I believe that figure would be something like 21 to 22 seconds, if the Earth revolved around the sun in a perfect circle and at a constant speed.

    I don’t recall reading anything about the inclination of the Earth’s axis in regards to the varying times of the sun’s transit, but I believe axial inclination has more of an effect than the Earth’s changing orbital speed. I believe the solar days are longer around the solstices and shorter around the equinoxes, primarily because of axial inclination.

    For now, enough of my musings . . .

    Bruce

  2. 2 Larry Sessions Jun 22nd, 2007 at 8:20 am

    Hey, Bruce! You’re probably more up on this than I am, so I will happily defer to you. There is a variation due to the inclination, but up until now I never knew the amount. It has to do with the sun’s apparent motion relative to the celestial equator, and my assumption was always that this is less of a factor than the distance (hence orbital speed) variation through the year. I suspect that this is because the orbital variation seems typically to be listed first, so I just assumed that it was more important. I also assume that the additional variations of 13-14 and 21-22 seconds are scaled off the equation of time (but you know what assumptions can make out of you!).

    HOWEVER (!) I’ve just found a graphic on the Greenwich Observatory/Nautical Maritime Museum website that definitely shows that the variation due to the tilt certainly contributes a greater amount to the overal variation. Take a look here: The equation of time.

    Thanks for pointing that out!

    Larry

  3. 3 Daniel Clements Sep 24th, 2007 at 10:03 am

    The difference between solar noon and your clock noon is very interesting. Did you know this was discovered many years ago and the effective calculations were put into a mechanical clock at the begging of the 18th century. We have actually a clock that can be seen on our website number 100 in clocks section, that shows this so called,’equation of time’ It is very rare, take a look, it is quite amazing.

    Regards

    Daniel

    http://www.pendulumofmayfair.co.uk

    Actual Link I believe is at http://www.pendulumofmayfair.co.uk/view.asp?pid=272&cat=Longcase Clocks

  1. 1 Space Shuttle & ISS Visible in Night Sky | This Crazy Cosmos Pingback on Feb 22nd, 2008 at 5:20 pm

Leave a Reply